Custom Font format not working

[STEVEMILLS04]

I downloaded a font file but installed the zipped version in error. I went into Excel and selected the new un-zipped font in a text box. I noticed the font style was not right so i deleted the font file in windows, closed Excel, un-zipped and installed the file again. When I go back into excel and select the font in a normal cell, all is well. When I go into any text-box and select the same text, it is not the right style. Name is right but the style is not what it should look like.

How do I fix this?