Index & match - same values

[Aussie Grid]

I've created a cote counting page which works fine until there are matching values and it then finds the 1st value only. The top 5 values are in a separate range and this is where the multiple values are read as the first only.(=INDEX($A$12:$AL$35,MATCH(AL6,$AL$12:$AL$35,0),1))
The Total votes column is populated by LARGE(1 - 5) and then Index and Match to get the names matching the totals.

B6-10 Top 5 players
=INDEX($A$12:$AL$35,MATCH(AL6,$AL$12:$AL$35,0),1)
AL6-10 Top 5 totals
=LARGE($AL$11:$AL$34,1)
=LARGE($AL$11:$AL$34,2) etc

A12-35 Players
B12-AK35 Votes
AL12-35 Total of votes
The top 5 results are OK until it meets 2 or more totals the same and then it only enters the name of the 1st instance of the tied scores.

Thankyou in advance for any and all help.
Aussie Grid

 

[jbeaucaire]

Tie Beaking is one approach. In this approach, names further up in the list are given precedence over lower names, so the "ranking" give seniority when appropriate. An example:

Excel Workbook
	A	B	C	D	E	F
1		Score	Rank		Top 5	Name
2	Name1	5	5		1	Name5
3	Name2	10	2		2	Name2
4	Name3	4	8		3	Name6
5	Name4	5	6		4	Name9
6	Name5	11	1		5	Name1
7	Name6	9	3
8	Name7	3	9
9	Name8	5	7
10	Name9	6	4
Sheet2

In this example, only Name1 makes the list as they were the first in the list to score a value that made the top 5. You can adapt that to your needs since you really only want 5 yes?

 

[Aussie Grid]

Thank you very much Jerry, I appreciate your time and effort.

Aussie Grid